[quote]this nest of vipers[/quote]
Ooooh - I think you just hurt our feelings :))
[quote] MBA ... Fancier school ... hailed as instant experts in my field at the tender age of 25[/quote]
You aren't exactly the only person to opine that
a young MBA is a young idiot.
There's nothing wrong with ongoing learning,
and after say 10 years of work experience some
business theory training won't hurt you, but
back when I was at cisco, I would try to save
people from wasting their money, getting an
MBA.
Look, I would tell them, buy one good textbook
on each of the following subjects:
- economics
- marketing
- finance
- accounting
and if there's a particular subject that spins
your crank (eg macro-economics) just keep
on reading.
Get the knowledge. The letters after your
name are almost useless.
Does that sound familiar? In aviation, I preach
that people should develop skill and knowledge,
and that the paper will follow.
NOT THE OTHER WAY 'ROUND.
PS I am NOT anti-B-school. My sister did her
Bcomm at U of T, then an MHA. My father
did his MBA at U of T, part-time, when he
was 40. I just don't worship the letters -
they don't mean a hell of a lot in my family.
One of my uncles (my mother's younger
brother) is a hoot. He was President
of Great Lakes Forest Products in Thunder
Bay, and then when onto become an EVP
at CN after the acquisition. Many decades
ago, when I was a kid, I asked him why he
never got an MBA, and he said he just got
some textbooks and read them (hint hint).
He was ruthless, interviewing engineers
that had MBA's. He would tell them that
they obviously liked to waste their time,
and why should he hire someone that likes
to waste their time?
Another one of my uncles worked for Peter
Lougheed as a cabinet minister. He never
bothered with an MBA, either. But you could
bet he had read a book or two.
Basically, there are two kinds of people in
the world.
1) the people that have to go on a course
and sit and watch powerpoint to learn
2) people who can read a book (or online)
and teach themselves.
Try really hard to be in group #2, because
you're going to spend the rest of your life
doing it.
Many pilots and ame's annoy me, because
they can only learn something when they
go on a course somewhere, and be fed
powerpoint pablum. Look, I say, there
are the manufacturer's operating and
maintenance manuals.
[url=
http://www.esscoaircraft.com/c-2401-civ ... craft.aspx][size=36pt][b]TRY READING THEM[/b][/size][/url]
N.B. What is fascinating is that there is
a strong correlation between a pilot or
ame being a "powerpoint pablum" baby,
and their disdain for instruction and the
people involved.
They don't realize what a joke they are -
the irony entirely escapes them, that
the only way they can learn, is by being
spoonfed by the people they hold in
contempt.
Too funny. I guess there's a lesson in
there for the human condition - people
hate the people, that help them.